In the interest of full disclosure, this story has links to a few products on Amazon. If you decide to buy these products from these links, I get a portion of the money. In the future, I may include such links to products, but do note that in all cases, these are products I have personally used and tested, and are products I believe in.
I will only include such ads when it facilitates the purchase of quality items.
An act of defiance.
A few years ago, I received a new razor blade in the mail. It came with two cartridges, and the handle. Just when I thought that three blades were enough to cope with any stubble i might have, the cartridge came with FOUR blades. I went through the two free blades in as many weeks, and since I had the handle, I thought i would just buy the blades for the handle.
I got to the store, and found that these blades cost $16 for three! I had never thought about how much i was spending on razor blades, so I looked at my old brand, and found that I was spending about $12 for a pack of four. I looked at the other brands, and this was about the standard pricing.
Then, scanning the racks, I found that I could pick up 10 old school safety razors for $5. I remembered that my grandpa gave me a safety razor about twenty years ago, and I still had it. In an act of technological defiance, I grabbed my old school razors at a fraction of the cost, and split.
Since I had my grandpa’s razor, the price of admission was free, but if you are a newcomer, you are going to have to get a handle. The most economical way to do it is to go to a second hand store. They usually have them lined up for five bucks a pop. In a lot of cases, they usually have new ones with cases for ten bucks. Until you know what you like, it really doesn’t matter which brand or style you get. Just get one that feels good in your hand. One of the brands that I have tried in the area of new razors is Merkur.
So, at this point, I had spend five bucks, for more than three times as many blades. But! Would one old school razor blade do the work of three modern blades?
But will it cut?
I ended up throwing a blade into my forty (at least) year old razor, and let it rip. To my surprise, I found that after I got used to how the razor worked (the angle and such) I was getting the best shave of my life. Over the years, I have found some tricks to getting an even better shave, and to my surprise, the best results were had with some of the most economical products.
Here are the things I learned. It took me awhile of wandering on my own. Armed with this info, you can have a barber shop quality shave every day, at a fraction of the super mega ultra blade cost:
- You should always make two passes when you shave. The first pass goes WITH the grain, to knock your stubble down, the second pass goes AGAINST the grain. This will give you a baby butt smooth shave.
- Take a look at your safety razor edgewise. You will see that it has an angle of about 30 degrees. This is the angle that you want to have flat on your face. Keep this angle as you move across your face, and you will keep that stubble in line.
- Once you are comfortable, you might want to try a real shaving cream. The stuff they sell in the mega stores come in two styles. Cheap fluffy soap, and expensive but not so effective creams. None of these products are really suitable for shaving. Once you have tried a real cream, you will never got back. Some brands I have used: Proraso
and Taylor of Old Bond Street
. Although they are a bit more expensive than their discount store counterparts at first, I find that each product lasts several (four to six!) months.
- If you venture out into using real shaving creams, you are going to need to pick up a brush. Brushes usually go from $15 – $40. My suggestion is to get a nice Badger Brush
in the $25 neighborhood. Mine has lasted for years, and I have not thought it was worth my while to replace it for a bigger model.
- If you decide to try other brands of razor blades (discount stores usually only carry their store brand), I have found that Merkur safety razor blades
are considerably more robust than discount brands.
So, do you save money?
In retrospect, I was spending about $15 a month on shaving supplies. This has been cut to:
| Razor Blades | $2.40 |
| Shave Cream | $2 |
| Total: | $4.40 per month |
So yes! Shaving like grandpa did saves a good deal of money, and works better than the latest blade technology.
How To
Okay, I found this video on youtube. While I think that all the information is valid, I found that since I shave in the shower, I can do it in five minutes, tops. So keep that in mind when they give you start hearing all the lengthy time estimates:
For a wealth of wet shaving information, and to learn to perfect your form, make sure to check Mark’s website and his youtube channel. Thanks, Mark for the excellent work.
So, if you decide to go this route, please let me know how it worked out for you. I would love to hear about your experiences.
Photo courtesy of Coffee Black and Egg White Photography
Addendum – 12/13/09
After using both Merkur blades and generic blades, I came to some conclusions. They are posted as a new entry on this blog.
#1 by quantum on July 13th, 2009
Quote
for old fashioned kids like myself who don’t want to buy it all on amazon, what discount stores carry these things?
#2 by makeinstall on July 13th, 2009
Quote
Using a straight edge razor that does not require frequent replacing is more frugal, environmentally sound and a proper “traditional” wet shave.
#3 by admin on July 13th, 2009
Quote
@quantum – to be absolutely frugal, here’s where i would go:
razor blades – any discount store like discount drug mart, rite aid, or cvs will have them.
handles – i have never seen one in a regular store. try a second hand store. i have even seen them at goodwill.
shaving cream – i have only seen this in a few old school pharmacies. i saw it at a store in wichita once.. i can get the name if you need it.
brush – you will have to shop around on this one.. i have seen them show up here and there at discount drug mart, but they are always cheapie ones. you really want a badger hair one… the reason is that badger hair retains water, rather then repels it.
thanks for reading!
#4 by admin on July 13th, 2009
Quote
@makeinstall – while i totally about using a straight razor, the cost of entry for a good razor is pretty high. you can spend up to a few hundred dollars on one.
i have one that my grandpa gave me at the same time, but i have never quite worked up the nerve to shave with it. maybe i will do that soon and report on it..
thanks for reading!
#5 by copperesque on July 13th, 2009
Quote
I have just found several razor handles in my collection of vintage goodies. I know I had a badger brush too… somewhere…. If I can find the round shaving soap around here, I will bust off some whiskers TONIGHT!
#6 by makeinstall on July 13th, 2009
Quote
You can get a decent entry straight razor for about £37 http://bit.ly/dRuqD which is a Cyril R Salter and seems to be quite reputable.
I agree that a good blade could cost you a lot but Im of the viewpoint that you are buying for life.
#7 by Topher on July 13th, 2009
Quote
I wish I had snagged my father’s “safety razor”. It was solid brass, and the top screwed off to replace the blade (instead of the newer twist-the-handle-and-it-opens-up style).
But despite that, I still think I have you beat. The trick is to shave in the shower, after washing the rest of yourself. This gives the hairs plenty of time to soften up. I shave my whole scalp and most of my beard, and blades in my Gillette razor last so long I forget when I last replaced them. I’m talking maybe six months. And when I replace them, it’s hard to tell any difference; the new blades aren’t all that much sharper than the old.
Then of course rinsing off under the shower is a snap.
#8 by Topher on July 13th, 2009
Quote
I forgot to add: my father had a special convex sharpening stone to resharpen his razor blades. I think that dated back to before you could get stainless steel blades, and they dulled pretty quickly.
#9 by Chadd on July 13th, 2009
Quote
Great post! We (RetroRazor) have great starter kits, but I highly encourage people to check out antique shops as mentioned to save a ton of money. Just make sure to sterilize before using, with a thorough boiling and some Scrubbing Bubbles!
In terms of blades, there is a huge variation in the way that different brands shave. As mentioned, the house brand blades (CVS, Walgreens, etc) can be pretty rough, and relatively expensive. There are dozens of brands from around the world available online, with prices ranging from $.10 – $.60 each when purchased in blocks of 100 (about a years worth). My favorite is the $.15 cent Turkish Derby (Stainless with platinum, teflon, tungsten, and ceramic edges), while the Merkur rips me up.
My suggestion: get a blade sampler pack on Amazon or West Coast Shaving, and find out which brand of razor blades is best for your skin and beard – there is really a difference once you try out a few. Then invest $15-20 on a years worth of blades.
It is a great way to save money and get a better shave!
Chadd
#10 by Riyality on July 18th, 2009
Quote
I’ve been shaving with a safety razor for over a year now. I’ve shaved my head consistently for the past 8 or so years since I was about 20.
I initially went this route due to the cost of the replacement blades on shavers these days. Best decision ever – My first products were a Basic Solingen Razor, Geo F. Trumpers Violets Shaving cream bowl, Vulfix badger brush and Merkur blades.
I don’t shave my head everyday but at least 3 times a week and my face at least 5 times a week, would you believe that the Trumpers shaving cream lasted 11 months. The 10 Merkur blades probably lasted 2 months at least. It has been an incredible cost saver and just a fantastic experience every time.
I’m using Proraso now, it’s also a great product, and I would recommend that as well as Trumpers. When it’s done (in a few months), I am going to try Trumpers sandalwood shaving cream.
I would recommend anybody try this. The very limited downside is that is takes a little longer and you do have to be more careful. Lots of upside though.
- R
#11 by ranjit on July 18th, 2009
Quote
I have been using a Merkur DE short razor for the last 3 years and can swear by it. It is the right weight and size.
I had to shop around a bit for blades, but the best value for money is the Wilkinson Sword classic (5 blades cost 4 dollars at a local pharmacy in Madison, WI) and each lasts 3-4 shaves depending on stubble length.
However, the best discovery i made 2 weeks ago was Pacific Shaving Oil (http://pacificshaving.com/), which is great for travelers who do not want to carry a brush and cream.
And I agree, once you go DE you never go back.
#12 by Jim Little on July 18th, 2009
Quote
Like you, I went back to the de razor because of the extortionist pricing of current, multiple blade razors. I also had to relearn the techniques, but it was well worth it.
#13 by Loren Nason on July 18th, 2009
Quote
I’ve always wanted to try one of these types of razors especially since i go through 4 Fusion cartridges a month.
The question i have is has anyone used this type of razor on their head? I shave my head and I try to shave twice a week.
#14 by DEMONICO on July 19th, 2009
Quote
Proraso is an italian brand, and here in italy u can find their products at almost every shop, even in the next door grocery or highway stops, and they are far cheaper than any other big brand product, such as gillette or wilkinson swords. I use since my first shave, when i was 14, and suggest to you the 100g before/after shave cream ( link ).It lasts for over an year of daily shaving, and its balsamic effect is usefull for sunburns too (tested). Greetings from deep southern italy, and sorry for my bad english.
#15 by Rob on July 19th, 2009
Quote
Can you take a straight razor on a plane?
#16 by StoneIsle on July 19th, 2009
Quote
A few words of caution about straight razors…
While a straight razor will give you a great shave, it is also more difficult to shave yourself with than a Double-Edge razor. This is why there were so many barbers around before the introduction of the DE razor. The conventional wisdom is that you use a straight razor when you shave others, and a DE razor on yourself.
Also, a razor-blade is just replaced (and recycled!) when it gets dull. A straight razor must be sharpened, and this can be an art onto itself, and requires equipment for this one purpose.
For those wanting to explore this topic further, I would highly recommend .
#17 by StoneIsle on July 19th, 2009
Quote
No preview, so I’m continuing my link to Badger & Blade here; http://badgerandblade.com/
#18 by admin on July 19th, 2009
Quote
@rob – i would imagine they would let you take one on a plane, but you cannot take it in your carry on..
it would have to be in your checked baggage..
can anyone verify this?
#19 by sbg on July 19th, 2009
Quote
About 15 years ago I bought such a razor at an antique store in Minnesota, and used the Wilkinson blades I found somewhere. I shave my legs and wonder if other women have tried using these razors — I knicked myself all over and I thought I was being careful. I still use my old Atra but would LOVE to go back to the old fashioned ones (with badger brush and all) but wonder if the gentlemen can suggest anything to us ladies? Any swimmers or cyclists shave other body parts, for instance?
#20 by Brian on July 19th, 2009
Quote
I’ve been seeing a lot of safety razor stuff lately and I am curious. But I’ve got a few questions, maybe some one has some insight.
I’ve used an electric razor for my whole life and it is mostly ok. I don’t grow a lot of hair so it does a tolerable job. And it is fast. I don’t have 20 minutes on a weekday to give to shaving but I’d like to try wet shaving when I have the time.
Can you mix the two techniques or will that just lead to some sort of horrific accident/condition? Should I even bother with wet shaving since I have don’t grow that much hair?
#21 by dwightk on July 19th, 2009
Quote
I found a brush and cream at Kroger… It was right in the usual shaving area… just toward the edge…
The brush was boar bristle and it lasted about a year before the bristles fell out as a group because the glue broke… I only paid $5 for it though.
I was about halfway through my second bar of cream at the same time.
#22 by emeryj on July 19th, 2009
Quote
There is nothing more satisfying than the manly art of a close shave.
I wanted to be more eco friendly, so I bought an electric shaver and trimmer. What a waste of money and my time.
I told myself that I would use the old razors until they were kaput. I’m still using the razors more than the shaver.
I remember how good it felt to swab my face with shaving sopa using a badger brush. It’s gotten me fired up and I am shopping for the right one now.
I can offer a few tips:
Keep that brush clean.
Remember Williams Lectric Shave… pre-shave that prepped beards for electric shavers? It works really well for wet shaving. Just spalsh on a little before soaping up. You can get an even closer shave.
The big enemy of a sharp shave is rust. Even stainless will rust. I’ve seen a few gadget out there aimed at getting the razor sry. If it’s dry, there is less chance for rust. Rust causes rough shaves.
My father’s old trick may work. He dropped his razor after cleaning it in a cup with a little olive oil.
#23 by mantic59 on July 19th, 2009
Quote
I’m the guy whose video you’ve linked. For those reading, you may be able to find some very inexpensive shaving products locally. In the US, Van Der Hagen shave soap is under $2 and works well. You can find it in many grocery stores, Walmart, Walgreens, etc (you may also find Williams shave mug soap as well but hold off on that–its a little difficult to lather for the beginner). Kiss My Face Moisture Shave is also available in many health-food outlets. In the UK, Boots has a shaving soap in a stick or a bowl, under a quid and it works well. Germany has Speick, the Middle-East has Arko, etc.
#24 by Tom on July 19th, 2009
Quote
Try here for everything.
Vermont Country Store
Men’s Grooming (19 July 2009)
http://www.vermontcountrystore.com/browse/Home/Apothecary/Mens-Grooming/D/30002/P/1:100:1000:10140
or
http://snipurl.com/nk7zt
They have the razor, blades, shaving mug, soap and brushes. They even have “Bay Rum” aftershave.
After seeing the prices in you blog and the online prices, I wish I would have kept my “old” shaving stuff.
Tom
#25 by Collin on July 20th, 2009
Quote
I’ve been using a double-edged razor for years, but I never bothered with shaving cream. I shave in the shower, giving the hot water a little time to soften the whiskers.
#26 by Eric on July 20th, 2009
Quote
How does this all work for HEAD shaving. I shave my noggin smooth every other day. It’s gotta be smooth and nick-free.
#27 by John W on July 20th, 2009
Quote
Don’t forget the Bay Rum.
#28 by Ay Uaxe on July 20th, 2009
Quote
Conditioner, like you would use on your hair, makes an excellent shaving conditioner/lubricant. It is light, super cheap and does to your beard the same thing it does to hair–softens and lubricates. Soap based shaving “creams” always over-dried my skin. In shower, after shampooing, get a nice, thick conditioner, any brand/scent you like, put about a quarter-sized glob in one palm, spread on hands, spread on face, spread remainder in hair (somehow, it seems to be just the right amount to leave in, if you have somewhat dry hair or need a little control help). Soap up body and run some hot water on your mirror to keep it from fogging. Turn off water. Shave. Turn water back on and rinse whatever you need or want to–I like to end with the coldest available water on the face–just gets me going. Your mileage may vary. Using conditioner in this way is so cheap, I can’t really even calculate how cheap it is–like nano-cents. The effect on my face has been remarkable–great close shave, no dryness or itching, like I was perpetually having to deal with before. Try it–there’s nothing to lose but the shower caddy space for the huge $1 bottle of bargain conditioner.
#29 by Brian W on July 21st, 2009
Quote
Merkur, merkur, merkur
I have tried supposedly sharper blades but these have a good balance of sharpness and usability(the sharper ones can be quite hard on your skin).
I agree with both the cream (Taylors) and a decent bit of badger (west country accent….Baaaaa-Jer) choices, and even though I still pick up my electric when my 9 months old has been up three nights in a row at 4:45am I still use my Merkur razor more and it feels good!
#30 by Chris W on August 28th, 2009
Quote
Just had to put a link in here to a site I have used with great satisfaction for nearly all of my shaving supplies since I switched to the double-edged method:
http://www.classicshaving.com
(no, I don’t work for them, I’m just a happy customer)
I’m just about to finish a tub of Taylor’s avocado shaving cream, and it’s been great. I already have a tub of Taylor’s lavender waiting to be tried.
#31 by mark on September 23rd, 2009
Quote
NEVER shave against the grain; idiot!
#32 by Wet Shave Enthusiast on December 13th, 2009
Quote
I am a Merkur DE razor user and it works great!
Wet-shaving also means less waste. Just think about all the non-recyclable plastic that goes into multi-blade cartridges and handles, and the aerosol cans that release harmful by-products into the environment. Switching to old-style shaving props won’t gain you entry into Green Peace by itself, but it is a good start.
#33 by Chewie on June 9th, 2010
Quote
@ Mark
Shaving against the grain CAN result in ingrown hairs. The trick is to make sure that if you shave against the grain, the last stroke should always be with the grain, even if your face is already smooth. The last stroke of the razor is what aligns the root of the hair, and if the last stroke is against the grain, the root is positioned to grow incorrectly. I used to get ingrown hairs all the time because my wife likes my face baby smooth, but a few months ago I heard about this technique and have had zero ingrown hairs since!